Answered: Installed SSL certificate not found in IIS 7 the drop down list

To fix this, use the MMC snapin to import the cert into PERSONAL, click it and grab the serial # line.  Go to console prompt, run

certutil -repairstore my "paste the serial # here" (you need the quotes)

then refresh MMC with personal certs, right click it - export - select everything except DELETE PRIVATE KEY, hit ok.  

Then go to IIS and IMPORT cert instead of finish request.